CHIRP
Confidential Human Factors Incident Reporting Programme
Demonstrating the link between working conditions and safety
https://chirp.co.uk/es/hot-topic/demonstrating-the-link-between-working-conditions-and-safety/

Demonstrating the link between working conditions and safety

Posted on 04.01.2023 by Adam Parnell


Dr Jess Sparks

In June 2022, the International Labour Organization (ILO) of the United Nations adopted “safe and healthy working environments” as their fifth category of Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work, demonstrating the intrinsic links between safety and decent work and unsafe and indecent work1. As fishing is notoriously one of the world’s most dangerous professions2, recognition of these links is also embedded in the ILO’s (2007) Work in Fishing Convention (c188) – which establishes minimum standards for decent work on board fishing vessels3. Decent work is just one end of the spectrum of working conditions on board fishing vessels, with egregious violations of human rights constituting forced labour, human trafficking, and modern slavery at the other end. In between decent work and forced labour are a range of conditions that may be exploitative and discriminatory but not in violation of labour laws (e.g., unequal pay for migrant fishers for equal, shared work with national fishers) or conditions that violate labour rights and protections, but may not amount to forced labour)4.

Bidirectional linkages between (un)safe working conditions and (in)decent work across fleets globally have also emerged in research. First, exploitative labour practices make the work on board vessels even more unsafe. For example, many exploited fishers working in fleets from Thailand5 to the UK4 to China6 report excessive working hours in contravention of ILO C188; denial and sometimes falsification of rest hours; and tied immigration schemes that blur the lines of what constitutes work – compelling some fishers to perform unvalued work (e.g., mending nets and vessel repairs) onboard the vessel while in port on their ‘rest’ days, or this may involve the denial or withholding of food and water until a certain amount of fish has been caught; as punishment for a poor catch.

Both scenarios compound the dangers already involved when working on a vessel as fatigued and malnourished fishers are more prone to making mistakes with serious consequences to their health and safety, and potentially the health and safety of others on board the vessel through no fault of their own. In research from the UK, migrant fishers in the sample were significantly more likely to incur injuries than national fishers4. Further, since many exploited fishers globally are transnational migrants, their precarious
immigration status may deny them access to medical care, including routine medical care that could offer early detection of illnesses associated with extreme and chronic fatigue and malnourishment.

Safety matters may also influence working conditions. There is some speculation, though it has yet to be empirically tested, that safety violations may be an early indicator of future exploitative labour practices, as these violations may be an early warning sign of a tipping point into decreasing profitability and the associated ‘corner cutting’ that often underpins the exploitation of crew7. And increasingly, the fishing industry needs to anticipate and plan for future scenarios where climate change will also likely exacerbate these links between safety and decent work, such as extreme storms, extreme heat, and wave and wind changes that may lead to occupationally hazardous work, longer trips at sea, longer working hours, and the need for more safety equipment. Suppose these impacts are not mitigated, and the industry is perceived as becoming more dangerous due to climatic changes. In that case, it could intensify crew labour shortages that are known to increase reliance on migrant fishers and drive exploitative practices.

The industry must also grapple with how to understand and frame these interconnections. On the one hand, contextualising working conditions within a more significant reference of safety offers the potential for greater stakeholder buy-in as it is frequently less divisive of a topic than the treatment of migrant crew. On the other hand, such contextualisation may also risk overlooking the systemic drivers of fishing crew exploitation and fair washing exploitative practices that do not reach the threshold of forced labour as decent work.

Fatigued and malnourished fishers are more prone to making mistakes with serious consequences to their health and safety

Dr Jess Sparks is a Research Assistant Professor at the Friedman School of Nutrition Science and Policy at Tufts University and a Research Fellow at the University of Nottingham Rights Lab. She has almost ten years of experience researching working conditions in the global fishing industry.

References

International Labour Organization. (2022, June). International Labour Conference adds safety and health to Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work. https://www.ilo.org/global/about-the-ilo/newsroom/news/WCMS_848132/lang--en/index.htm

Young, E. (2022, September). To improve fisheries health and safety at sea, U.N. delegates must act now. https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/articles/2022/09/02/to-improve-fisheries-health-andsafety-at-sea-un-delegates-must-act-now

International Labour Organization. C188- Work in Fishing Convention, 2007. https://www.ilo.org/dyn/normlex/en/f?p=NORMLEXPUB:12100:0::NO::P12100_ILO_CODE:C188

Decker Sparks, J. L. (2022). Letting exploitation off the hook? Evidencing labour abuses in UK fishing. https://www.nottingham.ac.uk/research/beacons-of-excellence/rightslab/resources/reports-and-briefings/2022/may/lettingexploitation-off-the-hook.pdf

Issara & International Justice Mission. (2017). Not in the same boat: Prevalence and patterns of labour abuse across Thailand’s diverse fishing industry. https://ijmstoragelive.blob.core.windows.net/ijmna/documents/studies/IJMNot-In-The-Same-Boat.pdf

Mongabay, Tansa, & The Environmental Reporting Collective. (2021, September). Worked to death: How a Chinese tuna juggernaut crushed its Indonesian workers. https://news.mongabay.com/2021/09/worked-to-deathhow-a-chinese-tuna-juggernaut-crushed-its-indonesianworkers/

Decker Sparks, J. L. & Hasche, L. K. (2019). Complex linkages between forced labor slavery and environmental decline in marine fisheries. Journal of Human Rights, 18(2), 230-245.

Demonstrating the link between working conditions and safety - CHIRP

Hot topic

January 2023

Demonstrating the link between working conditions and safety

Dr Jess Sparks

In June 2022, the International Labour Organization (ILO) of the United Nations adopted “safe and healthy working environments” as their fifth category of Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work, demonstrating the intrinsic links between safety and decent work and unsafe and indecent work1. As fishing is notoriously one of the world’s most dangerous professions2, recognition of these links is also embedded in the ILO’s (2007) Work in Fishing Convention (c188) – which establishes minimum standards for decent work on board fishing vessels3. Decent work is just one end of the spectrum of working conditions on board fishing vessels, with egregious violations of human rights constituting forced labour, human trafficking, and modern slavery at the other end. In between decent work and forced labour are a range of conditions that may be exploitative and discriminatory but not in violation of labour laws (e.g., unequal pay for migrant fishers for equal, shared work with national fishers) or conditions that violate labour rights and protections, but may not amount to forced labour)4.

Bidirectional linkages between (un)safe working conditions and (in)decent work across fleets globally have also emerged in research. First, exploitative labour practices make the work on board vessels even more unsafe. For example, many exploited fishers working in fleets from Thailand5 to the UK4 to China6 report excessive working hours in contravention of ILO C188; denial and sometimes falsification of rest hours; and tied immigration schemes that blur the lines of what constitutes work – compelling some fishers to perform unvalued work (e.g., mending nets and vessel repairs) onboard the vessel while in port on their ‘rest’ days, or this may involve the denial or withholding of food and water until a certain amount of fish has been caught; as punishment for a poor catch.

Both scenarios compound the dangers already involved when working on a vessel as fatigued and malnourished fishers are more prone to making mistakes with serious consequences to their health and safety, and potentially the health and safety of others on board the vessel through no fault of their own. In research from the UK, migrant fishers in the sample were significantly more likely to incur injuries than national fishers4. Further, since many exploited fishers globally are transnational migrants, their precarious
immigration status may deny them access to medical care, including routine medical care that could offer early detection of illnesses associated with extreme and chronic fatigue and malnourishment.

Safety matters may also influence working conditions. There is some speculation, though it has yet to be empirically tested, that safety violations may be an early indicator of future exploitative labour practices, as these violations may be an early warning sign of a tipping point into decreasing profitability and the associated ‘corner cutting’ that often underpins the exploitation of crew7. And increasingly, the fishing industry needs to anticipate and plan for future scenarios where climate change will also likely exacerbate these links between safety and decent work, such as extreme storms, extreme heat, and wave and wind changes that may lead to occupationally hazardous work, longer trips at sea, longer working hours, and the need for more safety equipment. Suppose these impacts are not mitigated, and the industry is perceived as becoming more dangerous due to climatic changes. In that case, it could intensify crew labour shortages that are known to increase reliance on migrant fishers and drive exploitative practices.

The industry must also grapple with how to understand and frame these interconnections. On the one hand, contextualising working conditions within a more significant reference of safety offers the potential for greater stakeholder buy-in as it is frequently less divisive of a topic than the treatment of migrant crew. On the other hand, such contextualisation may also risk overlooking the systemic drivers of fishing crew exploitation and fair washing exploitative practices that do not reach the threshold of forced labour as decent work.

Fatigued and malnourished fishers are more prone to making mistakes with serious consequences to their health and safety

Dr Jess Sparks is a Research Assistant Professor at the Friedman School of Nutrition Science and Policy at Tufts University and a Research Fellow at the University of Nottingham Rights Lab. She has almost ten years of experience researching working conditions in the global fishing industry.

References

International Labour Organization. (2022, June). International Labour Conference adds safety and health to Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work. https://www.ilo.org/global/about-the-ilo/newsroom/news/WCMS_848132/lang–en/index.htm

Young, E. (2022, September). To improve fisheries health and safety at sea, U.N. delegates must act now. https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/articles/2022/09/02/to-improve-fisheries-health-andsafety-at-sea-un-delegates-must-act-now

International Labour Organization. C188- Work in Fishing Convention, 2007. https://www.ilo.org/dyn/normlex/en/f?p=NORMLEXPUB:12100:0::NO::P12100_ILO_CODE:C188

Decker Sparks, J. L. (2022). Letting exploitation off the hook? Evidencing labour abuses in UK fishing. https://www.nottingham.ac.uk/research/beacons-of-excellence/rightslab/resources/reports-and-briefings/2022/may/lettingexploitation-off-the-hook.pdf

Issara & International Justice Mission. (2017). Not in the same boat: Prevalence and patterns of labour abuse across Thailand’s diverse fishing industry. https://ijmstoragelive.blob.core.windows.net/ijmna/documents/studies/IJMNot-In-The-Same-Boat.pdf

Mongabay, Tansa, & The Environmental Reporting Collective. (2021, September). Worked to death: How a Chinese tuna juggernaut crushed its Indonesian workers. https://news.mongabay.com/2021/09/worked-to-deathhow-a-chinese-tuna-juggernaut-crushed-its-indonesianworkers/

Decker Sparks, J. L. & Hasche, L. K. (2019). Complex linkages between forced labor slavery and environmental decline in marine fisheries. Journal of Human Rights, 18(2), 230-245.

Adam Parnell

Up next:

The CHIRP Charitable Trust

167-169 Great Portland Street
5th Floor
London
W1W 5PF

Registered in England & Wales
3253764
Registered Charity
1058262

Enquiries
Tel: 01252 378947
Email: mail@chirp.co.uk